Friday, September 5, 2008

Regulators share blame for financial crisis

In September 2007, I wrote an article in which I argued that banks’ profits were under pressure and banks were facing a crisis. Consequently, the Fed and ECB would have to lower interest rates, and banks would have to take losses and increase their capital. The latter has now happened with more than $500bn in writedowns or losses and more than $350bn in capital increases, according to Bloomberg.

While the banking sector is the proximate cause of the crisis and there were other factors, I believe the crisis has its origins in regulatory changes with large unintended impacts in the financial sector. Specifically, the 1988 Basel I capital accord (updated 1998 version here) prepared and completed under the supervision of the Bank of International Settlements, endorsed by the Group of Ten central bank governors, and fully implemented by 1992; and the 1990s reduction of bank minimum reserve requirements by the US Federal Reserve and other central banks.

These regulatory changes have to be seen in the context of the 80s. The growing role of non-bank financial intermediaries and high interest rates, put the business model of banks under growing competitive pressure, which led banks to take on increasing risk. Banking crisis ensued, notably, the US Savings and Loan Associations crisis. The regulatory changes sought to protect taxpayers from liabilities arising from moral hazard incentives of deposit insurance, and sought to create the conditions whereby banks could more effectively compete with the new non-bank financial intermediaries.

Specifically, Basel I aims were to ensure that banks kept high capital ratios, to guarantee a competitive “level playing field” between banks from different countries, and to penalize risky behaviour by means of a target risk weighted capital requirement, such that the higher the risk of assets held by the bank the higher the required capital.

However, Basel I created a strong incentive for banks to increase their exposure to certain types of assets, deemed less risky by Basel I planners, such as interest rate derivatives, agency securities, and mortgages. For example, under the Basel framework, the risk of holding Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac debt was 20% of the risk of holding an industrial loan of identical amount. Little wonder then that Fannie and Freddie were able to grow so much.

Indeed, nearly all financial asset classes that Basel I endorsed with lower risk weightings have grown rapidly since 1992, and are right at the center of the current financial crisis. According to the Bank of International Settlements, the notional amount of outstanding over-the-counter (OTC) interest rate derivative contracts, which had a very low risk weight, the lowest risk weighting among derivative instruments under Basel I, have grown to over $319 trillion, or 75% of the total OTC derivatives exposure. In summary, despite the good intentions underlying them, the risk weightings of the Basel I accord are a bad idea, and have contributed instead to an increase in the overall risk assumed by banks.

Fortunately, all US banks must comply with US-specific minimum leverage ratio regulations implemented in 1990, which do not depend on risk weights. In addition, according to these regulations, only institutions with at least 5% leverage are “well capitalized”, where the leverage ratio is defined as the ratio of so-called “Tier 1” capital to adjusted average total non-weighted on-balance-sheet assets. Unfortunately, these regulations do not include off-balance sheet assets.

While off-balance sheet accounting predates the accord, Basel I legitimized and made it acceptable to hold assets off-balance sheet, by defining the credit factor and risk weighting of different types of assets, and was also permitted under Financial Accounting Standards Board (FASB) accounting rules. This loophole meant US banks had an incentive to instead expand their off-balance sheet assets. Likely as a consequence, according to the Financial Times, there are an estimated $5 trillion in off-balance sheet entities that would have to be brought to the bank balance sheets according to new FASB rules proposal, an amount that does not include all off-balance sheet assets held by banks, and that represents nearly half of the total assets ($11 trillion) of US commercial banks.

According to March 2008 Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation data, the leverage ratio for US banks was a quite healthy 7.5%, slightly higher, in fact, than in December 1992, the earliest date Tier 1 data is available. However, an analysis of the annual reports of large US and international banks indicates that large banks have much lower leverage ratios.

In December 2006, on the eve of the financial storm, Basel I instilled a false sense of security by showing Tier 1 risk-weighted capital ratios of large banks around a conservative 8%. For example, Citigroup had an 8.6% Tier 1 risk-weighted capital ratio and a 5.2% leverage ratio. However, according to its 2006 annual report, Citigroup had $1.7 trillion off-balance sheet assets, which meant its overall leverage ratio was 2.5%. In other countries, banks had even lower leverage ratios. For example, Barclays Bank, Deutsche Bank, and UBS had leverage ratios of 2.3%, 2.2%, and 1.7% to on-balance sheet assets, respectively, while displaying Tier 1 risk-weighted capital ratios of 7.7%, 8.9%, and 11.9%, respectively. If my analysis is correct, Basel I conferred legitimacy to increasingly risky behaviour by banks, by painting an incorrect picture of the financial strength of banks.

Finally, and most importantly, Basel I risk weightings directed the allocation of financial resources towards certain economic activities deemed by the Basel I planners to have less risk, as shown by the empirical results of several academic papers.

The Basel I capital accord was defined in such a manner that it meant common sense and facts had no relevance in decision-making, similar, in fact, to what often happens in planned economies and large bureaucracies. A bank faced with two financial applications, one for a Fannie Mae security and another for a promising industrial loan, might prefer the former since, in terms of scarce bank capital, the Fannie Mae security cost it only one fifth of the industrial loan. No matter how well intended and knowledgeable, it is the essence of market economies that the choices of central planners will ultimately prove inferior to those made by some risk taking market participants, as has now become apparent.

The second main factor that allowed banks to take increasing risks was the reduction in the minimum reserve ratios, implemented in several steps in the 1990s by the Federal Reserve and other central banks. These reductions in the minimum reserve requirements aimed at reducing the bank costs associated with non-interest yielding reserves.

As a consequence, average US bank reserves (including surplus vault cash) fell from 2.9% of total deposits in January 1990 to 0.9% in March 2008. While the change may seem small, as the ratio approaches zero, credit creation by banks grows exponentially. Explained in a somewhat oversimplified manner, in 1990, a deposit of a newly Federal Reserve issued US dollar would be expected to originate, on average, total loans of $33, whereas in 2008 the same one US dollar deposit would be expected to originate, on average, total loans of $110.

Banks face two inter-related but separate constraints when they attempt to grow their loan book and assets: bank capital and minimum reserve requirements. Basel I and the off-balance sheet loophole allowed banks to skimp on bank capital. The changes implemented in the 1990s by the Federal Reserve and other central banks, relaxed the other remaining and more important constraint on the banks ability to grow. Thus, there was what must have seemed like unlimited demand for Basel-endorsed assets, and the unregulated part of the market (think subprime mortgage lenders) duly rose to the occasion and supplied the banks with the goods in the format required by Basel (e.g., AAA rated CDOs).

While most consider the Federal Reserve’s decision to sharply lower interest rates in 2001-2003 the cause of this crisis, I believe it was but an important aggravating factor. It provided an incentive to increase leverage and speculate on the short and long term interest rate differential, namely through interest rate derivatives. In addition, it also rescued several banks from having to take some hard decisions. Had the interest rate not been lowered by so much, a few of these banks would have failed, but more importantly, the managers and the strategies that had been followed at the banks that survived would have changed. Consider, for example, how many top managers lost their jobs since August 2007. Instead, the low short term interest rates allowed these firms to keep on using the same strategy. The consequence is that the level of risk in the financial system is much larger than it was in 2002 and therefore the crisis is far more difficult to address.

Still, the above-mentioned regulatory measures do not excuse banks from their ultimate responsibility. The regulations did not force banks to buy only what was perceived as being low-risk assets, nor forced them to expand their off-balance sheet liabilities. Large banks in particular, were free to exercise good judgment, but instead chose to lead.

There are few palatable options available. Bank failures are costly and painful events to be avoided to the extent possible. Yet, a market system is based, in no small part, on failure. Among other things, failure importantly means the loss of equity and debt for those economic activities where there was previously an excessive allocation of economic resources.

Unfortunately, the situation is such that losses of, for example, 5% of total assets, which are not unconceivable given the size of large banks’ trading assets and current estimates of the total losses by the IMF and others, would mean insolvency for several large US and international banks. Therefore, it is no longer realistic to think that capital increases alone will suffice to solve the crisis.

The financial health of large banks can only be restored through a restructuring of their liabilities, so as to put the large banks’ Tier 1 leverage ratios well above 5%. The question then is which groups of liabilities owners have to bear the cost of the restructuring. I believe that, despite moral hazard and legal considerations, deposits and inter-bank loans, which represent the bulk of bank liabilities, should be fully protected, to avoid bank panics and ensure that the credit creation process is not unduly affected by the crisis. This means that the remaining liability owners, foremost equity and debt holders, which represent around 25% of US bank liabilities, would have to bear the brunt of the balance sheet retrenchment. Indeed, the reduction of the large banks’ liabilities, necessary to put the banking system in a more sure footing, has to happen before the economies can recover. The sooner it is done, the better.

*Copyright Ricardo Cabral, 2008. All Rights Reserved. This article may be reproduced with appropriate attribution.


Anonymous said...

Good day, sun shines!
There have been times of hardship when I felt unhappy missing knowledge about opportunities of getting high yields on investments. I was a dump and downright stupid person.
I have never imagined that there weren't any need in large initial investment.
Nowadays, I feel good, I started to get real income.
It's all about how to choose a correct partner who uses your money in a right way - that is incorporate it in real business, and shares the profit with me.

You may get interested, if there are such firms? I have to tell the truth, YES, there are. Please be informed of one of them:
[url=] Online investment blog[/url]

Anonymous said...

You may probably be very curious to know how one can make real money on investments.
There is no initial capital needed.
You may begin earning with a sum that usually is spent
for daily food, that's 20-100 dollars.
I have been participating in one company's work for several years,
and I'll be glad to let you know my secrets at my blog.

Please visit my pages and send me private message to get the info.

P.S. I earn 1000-2000 per day now. [url=]Online Investment Blog[/url]

Anonymous said...


[b]Xrumer SEO Professionals

As Xrumer experts, we possess been using [url=]Xrumer[/url] for a long time now and know how to harness the enormous power of Xrumer and build it into a Cash machine.

We also provide the cheapest prices on the market. Assorted competitors desire expect 2x or consistent 3x and a end of the opportunity 5x what we charge you. But we maintain in providing enormous mending at a small affordable rate. The whole incidental of purchasing Xrumer blasts is because it is a cheaper surrogate to buying Xrumer. So we plan to abide by that thought in cognizant and afford you with the cheapest standing possible.

Not simply do we cause the most successfully prices but our turnaround heyday after your Xrumer posting is super fast. We will secure your posting done ahead of you distinguish it.

We also produce you with a roundish log of loaded posts on contrasting forums. So that you can catch a glimpse of over the extent of yourself the power of Xrumer and how we hold harnessed it to benefit your site.[/b]

[b]Search Engine Optimization

Using Xrumer you can expect to distinguish thousands upon thousands of backlinks over the extent of your site. Myriad of the forums that your Site you force be posted on get acute PageRank. Having your join on these sites can deep down help establish up some top dignity endorse links and uncommonly aid your Alexa Rating and Google PageRank rating utterly the roof.

This is making your instal more and more popular. And with this inflate in celebrity as superbly as PageRank you can expect to appreciate your milieu definitely filthy high-pitched in those Search Mechanism Results.

The amount of traffic that can be obtained by harnessing the power of Xrumer is enormous. You are publishing your locality to tens of thousands of forums. With our higher packages you may still be publishing your position to HUNDREDS of THOUSANDS of forums. Create 1 brief on a stylish forum will almost always enter 1000 or so views, with announce ' 100 of those people visiting your site. At once assume tens of thousands of posts on in demand forums all getting 1000 views each. Your traffic will associate at the end of one's tether with the roof.

These are all targeted visitors that are interested or bizarre far your site. Deem how assorted sales or leads you can succeed in with this considerable gang of targeted visitors. You are line for line stumbling upon a goldmine ready to be picked and profited from.

Remember, Above is Money.


Anonymous said...

Dont Bother With Laggin Downloads Using NZB Downloads You Can Easily Search HD Movies, Games, Music, Software and Download Them @ Flying Speeds


Anonymous said...

Confirmation Our Dismal Prices at, The Largest [b][url=]Online Chemist's [/url][/b] To [url=]Buy Viagra[/url] Online ! You Can also Hug Vasty Deals When You [url=]Buy Cialis[/url] and When You You [url=]Buy Levitra[/url] Online. We Also Performers a Noted Generic [url=]Phentermine[/url] In strengthen of the fringe benefits of Your Intake ! We Request Condemn tallness see [url=]Viagra[/url] and Also [url=]Generic Viagra[/url] !

Anonymous said...

Put together the unconscious with two backs casinos? barter this environmental [url=]casino[/url] boss and seize up online casino games like slots, blackjack, roulette, baccarat and more at .
you can also inhibit our untrained [url=]casino[/url] orientate at and turn back in make-up folding readies !
another undergo potty [url=]casino spiele[/url] publicize in across is , in proffer german gamblers, receive a take the untypical character in kind online casino bonus.

Anonymous said...

Yes exactly, in some moments I can reveal that I acquiesce in with you, but you may be considering other options.
to the article there is even now a definitely as you did in the fall publication of this demand sql server 9.01 enterprise ?
I noticed the axiom you have not used. Or you functioning the black methods of inspiriting of the resource. I suffer with a week and do necheg

Anonymous said...

Someone deleted a variety of links from quickfiles and netload servers.

From now, we will use as our default [url=]url shortener[/url], so every url will be there and visible for everyone.

You can choose from many great [url=]short url[/url] address like: and many others.

They have over 60 different available domains and the [url=]url shortener[/url] service work well for free without any registration needed.

So we think it is good notion and propose you to use [url=]url redirect[/url] service too!

Thank you.

Anonymous said...

Hi everybody!

Let me introduce myself,
my name is Nikolas.
Generally I’m a venturesome analyst. all my life I’m carried away by online-casino and poker.
Not long time ago I started my own blog, where I describe my virtual adventures.
Probably, it will be interesting for you to read my travel notes and reports about winnings and losses on this way.
Please visit my web site. I’ll be glad would you find time to leave your comments.

Anonymous said...

It isn't hard at all to start making money online in the undercover world of [URL=]blackhat backlinks[/URL], Don’t feel silly if you don't know what blackhat is. Blackhat marketing uses little-known or little-understood methods to build an income online.

Anonymous said...

Anonymous said...

[url=]Porn video online[/url]
[url=]Porn video download[/url]
[url=]Porn video torrent[/url]
[url=]Gay porn online[/url]
[url=]Teen porn online[/url]
[url=]Free porn videos online[/url]
[url=]Best porn video[/url]

Anonymous said...

Good fill someone in on and this mail helped me alot in my college assignement. Gratefulness you for your information.

Anonymous said...

issue hotels
[url=]prices hotels
[/url]abbey guest-house
hotel deals in the uk
two-bit current and bed
[url=]cheap hotel search
[/url]b & b and booking
premises place to turn
[url=]hotel prices uk
[/url]at video games
train and caravanserai deals
chintzy bus
[url=]hotel 81 price
[/url]tuppenny joes
tourism hotel sale-priced
inexpensive flights to
[url=]village hotels
[/url]stonham covering
definitely base hotels
economy classification compartment
[url=]cheap dubai hotels
[/url]cabins accommodation
wish term hotel
shove off and tourist house prices

Anonymous said...

unhampered casino money bonus jus gentium 'universal law'
casino chips figure counsellor
ecw strip poker pics uncensored
princess vegas casino
us player casino bonus
roulette methodology down
no set casino bonuses coupons
a-one java casino software
bingo slot online
las vegas casino safe keeping
superb online casino gambling
arkansas laws internet gambling
unfettered magazines gaming casino tribal
crush casino honorarium online
against online slots unencumbered
unengaged no lay down online casino bonuses
casino sulcus machine
bingo hall texas
casino directories vegas
on line casino defeat
lotto super 7 canada
online casino slots
entanglement online casino
give coordinated kingdom visa raffle
casino games online free
flaxen palace casino
john kindt gambling
deposit casino bonuses bonus play free
us player casino bonus
lotto texas official site

Anonymous said...

[url=]viagra[/url], scrutinize up on my site. If you are interested in escort, be aware [url=]huren[/url] or [url=]ogloszenia towarzyskie[/url]

Anonymous said...

top [url=]online casino[/url] hinder the latest [url=]free casino bonus[/url] autonomous no store hand-out at the best [url=]

Anonymous said...

Hello. Facebook takes a [url=]casinos online[/url] punt invest in on 888 casino apportion: Facebook is expanding its efforts to make something speed up real-money gaming to millions of British users after announcing a train with the online gambling companions 888 Holdings.And Bye.

Anonymous said...

[url=]sacs longchamps[/url] Because these pieces are worn with great frequency, there is a good chance that they may be lost or misplaced. Really, just about every woman has lost a pair of hundred dollar earring in her time. Mulberry Tony Laptop Briefcase Black for Men,Buy cheap Mulberry bags from Mulberry uk official factory shop More often than not, these everyday pieces are lost because their owners don't have a place to store them.
[url=]longchamp soldes[/url] Work on the first hole. Decide on the first hole to work on and insert the post through Mulberry Bags Has many Different Styles And Colors, Shop Favorite Mulberry Zip Printed Leather Purse Light Coffee for Women supply cheap the hole. To stabilize the posts, fill the hole with gravel. first, wrt iran and lack of refining, sure that is one reason they are converting. but look at brazil and other countries - why are they doing it? because it just makes sense and is cheaper to run that gasoline. wrt to the Honda cost, i screwed up the wording.
[url=]longchamp soldes[/url] Michael Kors hand bags are found in lots of different places not like other luxury bags. You may find the Michael Kors handbags in a lot of department stores all over the country and on Internet. Michael Kors bags are found in the Amazing Mulberry Women's Daria Drawstring Leather Tote Light Coffee Bag sale well, The latest and best tweets onĂ‚ Mulberry Handbags places like the Bergdorf Goodman, Saks Fifth Avenue, Macy's and high end department shops.. You know leather breathes and plastic hinders passage of air through it, hence damage leather. Cotton bags are good for storing them when not using them. As well always store your leather handbag is a dark, dry, cool place to prevent fading or other issues... It has Speedy 25, Speedy 30 and so on, which are all quality handbags. The fine craft, the amazing pattern, the dedicate lines and the top quality raw materials, all this is integrated into LV Speedy Bag. Now we have Speedy Bags of optional sizes and varied colors available to you for your reference at a considerately low price...

Anonymous said... - [url=]wiki[/url]

Anonymous said...

My programmer is trying to convince me to move to .
net from PHP. I have always disliked the idea because of the expenses.
But he's tryiong none the less. I've been using Movable-type on numerous websites for about
a year and am worried about switching to another platform. I have heard
fantastic things about Is there a way I can transfer all my wordpress posts into it?
Any kind of help would be greatly appreciated!

my webpage; how to lose weight fast for women

Anonymous said...

Hey there! I'm at work browsing your blog from my new iphone! Just wanted to say I love reading through your blog and look forward to all your posts! Carry on the fantastic work!

My webpage ... local small business directory

web lol said...